• Skip to main content

Laboratory for Advancing Dispute Resolution Skills

From the Dispute Resolution Institute at Mitchell Hamline School of Law

Bar Fight

  • Home
  • RESOURCES
  • DRI PRESS
  • COLLECTIONS
    • Marjorie Corman Aaron
    • Jim Coben
    • Ken Fox
    • Jim Hilbert
  • NEXTGEN

Resources > Bar Fight

Duration: 100 minutes plus debrief

NextGen: Yes 

Teaching Notes: Yes

Skills: ADR | Negotiation 

Skill Levels: Basic | Intermediate 

Type of Resources: Simulation 

Subjects: Doctrinal Subjects | Torts 

Modality: Both Online and In-Person

Participants: groups of 4

Bar Fight 

Jim Hilbert 

 

This is a compact simulation intended for law students for negotiating a personal injury settlement agreement. The underlying scenario involves a bar fight allegedly started by the plaintiff (Taylor), where the plaintiff was injured by employees of a mythical local bar (Zira’s). Taylor alleges that he was injured and lost jobs as a result of the incident. His alleged damages include medical expenses, lost wages and emotional distress. Taylor has not yet filed a complaint, and the parties are interested in negotiating an early resolution to the dispute.

Bar Fight: Overview (PDF)

Bar Fight: Instructor Notes & Background (PDF)

Bar Fight: Confidential Packet for Defendant Zira’s (PDF)

Bar Fight: Confidential Packet for Defendant’s Attorney (PDF)

Bar Fight: Confidential Packet for Plaintiff Taylor Heston (PDF)

Bar Fight: Confidential Packet for Plaintiff’s Attorney (PDF)

 

Laboratory for Advancing Dispute Resolution Skills Teaching

Dispute Resolution Insitute at Mitchell Hamline School of law

875 Summit Avenue, Saint Paul, MN 55105-3076 | [email protected]

© 2026 Mitchell Hamline School of Law in affiliation with Hamline University.