• Skip to global navigation
  • Skip to page content
  • Skip to section navigation
  • Skip to site index
Mitchell Hamline School of Law
Menu Search
  • Home
  • About
    about

    About

    Mitchell Hamline School of Law, located in St. Paul, Minnesota offers a rigorous, practice-based experience, preparing graduates to serve clients and communities. Our motivated students study full time or part time, on-campus or partially online in the way that fits their lives.

    • Accreditation
    • Awards, Rankings, and Recognition
    • Blended Learning at Mitchell Hamline
    • Board of Trustees
    • Civic Engagement
    • History
    • Employment at Mitchell Hamline
    • Life at Mitchell Hamline
    • Notable Alumni
    • Partnerships
    • Pre-Law Programs
    • President and Dean
    • Rosalie Wahl Legal Practice Center
    • Affiliation with Hamline University
  • Academics
    academics

    Academics

    Mitchell Hamline School of Law

    Academics

    Academics
    • A degree that prepares you for practice
    • J.D. Enrollment Options
    • Centers and Institutes
    • LL.M. and Other Degree Programs
    • Journals and Law Reviews
    • Study Abroad
    • Non-Degree Certificates
  • Prospective J.D. Students
    prospective-j-d-students

    Prospective J.D. Students

    Learn about the application process and connect with our Admissions team.

    • Admissions Materials
    • Admissions Team
    • Applying
    • Frequent Questions
    • Licensure
    • Student Profile
    • Tuition and Financing
    • Connect with Mitchell Hamline
    • Yellow Ribbon Law School
    • ABA Required Disclosures
    • Employment Summary Reports
  • Faculty
    faculty

    Faculty

    Faculty
    • Faculty and Academic Deans
    • Board of Trustees
    • Senior Leadership
    • Adjunct Faculty
    • Faculty Emeritus
    • Faculty Experts Guide
    • Faculty Publications
    • Mitchell Hamline Open Access
  • Alumni
    alumni

    Alumni

    Alumni
    • Alumni Association Board
    • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Mentoring
    • Alumni Award Recipients
    • Elected and Appointed Officials in Minnesota
    • Notable Alumni
  • Library
    library

    Library

    Library
    • Catalog
    • Circulation
    • Computing
    • Document Delivery
    • Interlibrary Loan
    • Library Staff
    • Policies
    • Printing / Scanning / Copying
  • Giving
    giving

    Giving

    Giving
    • Impact of Giving
    • Recognition and Thanks
    • Mitchell Hamline Priorities
    • Planned Giving
    • The Annual Fund
    • Staff
  • Admitted Students
    admitted-students
    • Admitted Students 101
    • Important dates
    • Tuition and Financial Aid
    • Merit Scholarships
    • Student Resources
    • Law School Preparation
  • Current Students
    current-students
    • Academic Excellence Program
    • Bookstore
    • Career and Professional Development
    • Competitions and Moot Courts
    • Counseling Services
    • Culture and Inclusion
    • Dean of Students
    • Disability Services
    • Financial Aid
    • Information Technology Services
    • Registrar
    • Student Finances and Payroll
    • Warren E. Burger Law Library
  • Career Development
    career-development
    • Resources for Students
    • Solo and Small Firm Practice
    • Resources for Employers
    • Resources for Alumni
    • Reciprocity
    • Staff
    • Employment and Salary Reports
    • Non-Discrimination Policy
  • Faculty & Staff Web
    faculty-staff-web
    • The Summit
    • Technology Services For Faculty and Staff
  • News
    news
    • CLE, Lectures, and Conferences
    • Faculty Publications
    • Media Experts Guide
    • Subscribe
  • Tech
    tech
    • Course Design and Teaching
    • Record, Broadcast, and Go Live
    • Network and Other Technical Support
    • Jenzabar One System Upgrade
    • Tech Knowledge Base
  • Email
  • Canvas
  • Office 365
  • Zoom
  • Password Reset
  • Starfish
  • VPN
  • Print (Uniflow)
  • 12twenty
  • MyMitchellHamline
  • Faculty/Staff J1 Web
  • This website

Mitchell Hamline Law Journal of Public Policy and Practice

Tips from Appellate Jurists

Law Journal

  • Current Volume
  • Issue Archive
  • The Quadriga
  • Membership Selection
  • Editorial Board
  • Journal Associates
  • Symposia
  • Submissions
  • Current Student Mailing List
  • Alumni Mailing List
  • Alumni Networking List

Mitchell Hamline Law Journal of Public Policy and Practice

875 Summit Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55105

651-227-9171
1-888-962-5529

jlawprac @mitchellhamline.edu

Volume 47 Masthead

Editor-In-Chief
Margaret Galles

Production Editor
Serra-Maire Anderson

Policy Editor
Ashley Bianco

Primary Editor
Kiara Green

Primary Editor
Madison Wolfe

Managing Editor
Auria Gauger

Articles Editor
Alexander Moe

Articles Editor
Amy Coogan

Digital Editor
Ashley Scanlan

Symposium Editor
Courtney Chapple

Faculty Advisor
Professor Peter Knapp

Posted: March 26, 2019

Introduction

On March 15, 2019, the Appellate Practice Section of the Minnesota State Bar Association held the annual Appellate Practice Institute in conjunction with Minnesota CLE. A panel consisting of Justice Natalie Hudson, Judge Matthew Johnson, and Judge Peter Reyes discussed tips for appellate practitioners. This article outlines tips that were shared by the appellate jurists.

Jon Schmidt
Jon Schmidt is an Assistant Hennepin County Attorney in the Special Litigation Division – Appeals Unit, focusing exclusively on criminal appeals. Prior to joining the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office, Jon was a shareholder at Briggs and Morgan with a varied appellate and litigation practice. After graduating from William Mitchell, Jon clerked for Judge Natalie Hudson on the Minnesota Court of Appeals, and then for Judge Myron Bright on the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. Jon is also a Fellow of the American Academy of Appellate Lawyers.

Briefs Tips

Briefs should be just that: brief. Brevity is a good thing. Cut out repetition. Cut out telling the court what you are about to tell them (instead just tell them). Cut out long case summaries where they are unnecessary (unless you are comparing your case to something that is nearly identical).

Clarity is key. Clearly state the legal issues and the issue statements. Organization within an appellate brief helps with clarity, focuses the argument, and often keeps the brief shorter.  Look at your table of contents to determine if the brief is organized well.  Your table of contents should tell the story of what happened, what the issues are about, and why you win.

Don’t throw mud. Drop the hyperbole.

Finally, candor is of the utmost important. It is also an attorney’s ethical duty. Don’t overplay your hand. The facts are what they are. The record is what it is. And a case says what it says. If you have to concede an issue, concede it. The appellate courts will greatly appreciate you making concessions where you must.

Images in Briefs

All the jurists agreed that images can be very useful. Images are not necessary in every case, but in certain cases a timeline or graph can be extremely helpful. Maps, in particular, can be quite helpful to orient the judges to the facts of the case. When using maps or images, they can be placed right into the text of the brief or included in the addendum.

Judge Johnson reminded everyone that the appellate rules (Rule 130.02) allows litigants to put up to fifty pages of additional materials in the addendum.  A map or image can be useful material to include in an addendum.  Litigants should also consider including the key statute, the contract at issue, important exhibits, or the most powerful testimony in the addendum. Use discretion, but use the addendum.

Technology on Appeals

The jurists had different approaches to technology. Judge Reyes only reads from his computer – the briefs, cases, record, etc. He noted that, as a result, footnotes can be distracting because he needs to scroll to the bottom of the page to read the footnote, then scroll back up to resume the text.

Judge Johnson and Justice Hudson blend between reading on computers and reading on paper. The approach depends on the case, the location of the argument, and where the Judge or Justice is preparing. Often, both will read on their computers when at home or working remotely.

Oral Arguments

Welcome questions.  Oral arguments is not the attorney’s time to give a speech or a closing argument.  A good advocate will engage in a discussion about the case with the panel.  This is the first time the judges are talking about the case with each other and you, as the litigant, should engage in that conversation.

Answer the question.  If you don’t answer the question, you will be asked the question again.  The judge is asking the question for a reason and wants an answer.

Be flexible.  An attorney may want to approach an argument by discussing the issues in order.  But the judges may be most concerned about issue 2, not issue 1.  Be prepared and flexible to address the issue that the judges want to discuss.  Do not tell the judges that you will get to that issue later (or in a minute).

Conclusion

The jurists were complimentary of Minnesota’s appellate bar.  The tips that the panel offered can assist the appellate judges in reaching their decision and, ultimately, in helping the litigant be successful on appeal.

Category: The Quadriga

Previous Post:
Legislative Efforts to Silence Dissent: The Rise and Fall of Minnesota’s Anti-Protest Bill
Next Post:
An Overview: The Impact of Rideshare Insurance on the Role of Liability Insurance in Motor Vehicle Accident Cases


  • About
  • Academics
  • Prospective Students
  • Faculty
  • Alumni
  • Library
  • Giving
  • Admitted Students
  • Current Students
  • Career Development
  • Faculty and Staff

The Mitchell Hamline J.D.

  • In the Classroom
  • In Simulated Practice
  • In the Real World

J.D. enrollment options

  • Full time
  • Part time, day or evening
  • Blended learning

Specialized Degree Programs

Journals and Law Reviews

Study Abroad

Centers & Institutes

  • Center for Law and Business
  • Dispute Resolution Institute
  • Health Law Institute
  • Institute to Transform Child Protection
  • Intellectual Property Institute
    • Patent Law Program
  • Native American Law and Sovereignty Institute
  • Public Health Law Center

Certificate Programs

Special Programs

  • Expert Witness Training Academy
  • Minnesota Justice Foundation
  • Mitchell Hamline Fellows Program
  • Office of Academic Excellence
  • Pre-Law Programs
  • Self-Help Clinic
  • Sex Offense Litigation and Policy Resource Center
  • Truth and Action
  • Upper Midwest Patent Assistance

General Information

  • Consumer Information
    (ABA Required Disclosures)
  • Campus Security Report
  • Student Complaint Process
  • Academic Calendars
  • Civic Engagement
  • CLE, Lectures, and Conferences
  • Culture and Inclusion
  • Department/Office Contacts
  • Directions, Maps, and Parking
  • Directories
  • Privacy Statement

Action Items

  • Ask a Question
  • Make a Gift
  • Subscribe to Email News
  • Jobs at Mitchell Hamline
  • Apply for Admission
  • Hire a Student or Graduate
  • Shop the Bookstore
  • Sexual Misconduct Policy
  • Sexual Misconduct Policy
  • ABA Required Disclosures
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • Linked In
  • Instagram

875 Summit Avenue, Saint Paul, MN 55105-3076 1-888-962-5529 651-227-9171

Mitchell Hamline School of Law

© 2025 Mitchell Hamline School of Law in affiliation with Hamline University.

Building hours
Monday–Friday: 7:30 am–10:30 pm
Saturday–Sunday: 9:00 am–4:00 pm